Subscribe to our RSS feed
EconLife.com connects economics to everyday life, current events and history.

Tag Archives: drachma

euro zone map

The Greek government needs its newest bailout infusion. But in return, austerity would include (among many other requirements) cutting certain civil servants’ salaries by as much as 35%, raising the retirement age again but this time to 67, and plunging the number of associate professors at public universities from 15,226 to 2,000. The Greek Parliament has to decide before November 12.

This takes us to olive oil.

In a March 2012 report, the consulting firm McKinsey & Company proposed a development plan for Greece that would be spearheaded by an Economic Development and Reform Unit. Industry by industry, specific changes were proposed. Looking at what McKinsey suggests for olive oil as a prototype example, do you think the Greeks can leap from their current crisis to economic growth during the next decade?

Here are the broad goals and then the olive oil plan:

Broad Goals:

  • Focus on tradable sectors
  • Attract foreign and domestic investment
  • Generate more productivity
  • Ensure tax compliance
  • Create employment opportunities
  • Simplify bureaucracy
  • Expand the court system

 

Olive Oil:

Although Greece is the world’s third largest olive oil producer, Italy is the main beneficiary. Because Greece sends its olive oil in bulk to Italy where it is packaged and marketed, Italy enjoys a 50% premium from the price of the retail product. McKinsey suggests that instead, Greece has to add to its factory capacity at home, develop a “cachet” for the “Made in Greece” label, and sell directly to targeted markets abroad. North America, the UK, Germany & Austria, and the Balkans would be top priority markets. (The McKinsey chart below is interesting.)

Reading the report, you start to realize that while Greece has immense economic potential, the chasm between their current plight and jumpstarting economic development is massive. In addition, since the report was issued, Fage moved its headquarters to Luxembourg and Coca-Cola switched its main stock market listing to London.

Can olive oil and tourism, feta and yogurt help to fuel the Greek economy?

Sources and Resources: My current facts about Greece receiving its newest tranche are from this NY Times article. Thinking of the future, the McKinsey report resounds until, I suspect, it connects to Greece’s political and economic problems. As a counterpoint, you might want to look at this Business Insider slide show detailing the impact of a “Grexit” and this econlife post about Greece.

From McKinsey, “Greece 10 Years Ahead,” p. 49:

Greek Economic Development and Olive Oil

 

 

Posted by: adminEcon
Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
Comments (0) Add a Comment

How much should cities plan for the storm of the century?

Like New York’s Knickerbocker Bank in 1907 or Jimmy Stewart’s 1930s bank in It’s a Wonderful Life, the ingredients of a classic run include distraught depositors and rumors of a bank’s imminent demise. Lines are long, emotions are volatile and, as the Washington Post tells us about the Knickerbocker run,  ”Stacks of green currency, bound into thousand dollar lots, were piled on the counters beside the tellers.” However, as Jimmy Stewart finally has to explain–your money is not here; it is in the loans we gave your neighbors for their homes. Unimpressed, people want their savings. As a last resort, Stewart gives them his honeymoon cash and the Knickerbocker closes its doors.

Fast forward to 2012 and Greece.

Called a slow run or maybe a bank jog, money is leaving Greek banks. 21.9% unemployment means many people need their savings for everyday expenses. Others are worried that if Greece leaves the euro zone, their euro savings will become drachma savings and the drachma could be worth 60% less. They are also concerned about deposit insurance. Yes, Greek accounts are insured. But by whom? A Greek government with no money. Then, to make all of this even worse, Greek banks own Greek bonds that markets have massively discounted.

What does it all add up to? “Drachmageddon.”

Also, it returns us to the timeless prototype of a “perfect financial storm” that 2 Darden School scholars describe in their history of  The Panic of 1907. If you would like to read more of this amazingly prescient list (pp.4-5) here is an excerpt from their book.

  1. An overly complex system that enables contagion.
  2. Previously exuberant attitudes to growth.
  3. Narrowing financial margins of safety.
  4. Leadership that diminishes confidence and elevates uncertainty.
  5. Unforeseen adverse economic events.
  6. The emergence of a downward spiral with self-reinforcing pessimism.
  7. Ineffectual collective problem solving.

 

While this NPR Planet Money podcast, this NPR article and this CNN article describe current Greek banking problems, the Bruner/Carr detailed history, The Panic of 1907, wonderfully conveys the characteristics of typical financial storms. Please note also that the term, “drachmageddon” came from Greek financial journalist Kostas Mariolis.

Posted by: adminEcon
Tags: , , , , , , , , ,
Comments (0) Add a Comment

16618_3.9_000008354384XSmall

Saying, “It is a small step for the euro zone and a big step for Estonia…” the Estonian prime minister celebrated his country’s formal entry into the Western economic world. On January 1, 2011, Estonia switched from the kroon to the euro (and many bought new wallets because the size of their currency had changed). Looking forward to more trade and greater national security, Estonia very much wanted euro zone membership.

The lowest in the euro zone, Estonia’s debt to GDP ratio during 2010 was 6.6%–far below the euro zone rule that national debt could not exceed 60% of GDP. According to this NPR Planet Money podcast, when Estonia experienced a severe recession during 2009, even the president, who grew up in New Jersey, took a 10% salary cut.

And then we have Greece. Switching from the drachma to the euro in 2001, Greece knew, according to this BBC article, that she would have to display more fiscal discipline as a euro zone member. You know what happened. Her 2010 debt to GDP ratio was 142.8%. The story of Greece’s response since 2009 is here.

The Economic Lesson

Monetary policy involves the supply of money and credit. A country’s fiscal policy relates to taxes, spending and borrowing. Estonia and Greece share the same monetary policy while each has its own fiscal policy. And therein lies the problem.

When countries borrow, they are implementing fiscal policy. But who buys their debt? Banks–the same banks that participate in monetary policy. So, because banks link fiscal and monetary policy, if one goes awry, the other is affected.

An Economic Question: How might Estonia experience the impact of Greece’s fiscal policy?

Posted by: adminEcon
Tags: , , , , , ,
Comments (0) Add a Comment

16449_3.9_000008354384XSmall

According to a 2002 BBC report, Greece was the least prepared to make the switch to the euro in 2002. During the transition only 1/6 of all businesses in Greece had received their euros.

Now, Greece remains a dysfunctional euro nation. Can it leave? Not easily. (This NBER paper details the issues.

If Greece were to leave the euro zone, it would have to…

  • create and print “new” drachmas.
  • switch all contracts from euros to new drachmas. Loans, mortgages, wages, bank deposits, taxes, bonds, all would need to change.
  • restock and reprogram all computers, vending machines, and ATMs.

Also though, having power over its own monetary and fiscal policy, it could…

  • stimulate tourism and exports by depreciating its currency.
  • have more flexibility when spending and taxing.
  • unilaterally restructure its sovereign debt.

But then…

  • French and German banks would have to “mark to market” the value of the Greek bonds that they own.
  • Other weaker euro zone nations might decide to copy Greece.

Would the ripple lead to the demise of the euro zone?

The Economic Lesson

Countries typically use monetary and fiscal policy to affect domestic economic conditions. Monetary policy involves the supply of money and credit. Fiscal policy relates to spending, taxing and borrowing.

Recession? Borrow and spend more. But euro zone nations are not supposed to let deficits exceed 3% of GDP. Lower interest rates? The euro zone makes the monetary decisions.

An Economic Question: You can see the problem. Countries with different economic conditions lack the flexibility to respond to their own special needs. For example, how would fiscal policy differ for a nation with low unemployment and one with considerable joblessness? (Here, you can check unemployment statistics for the euro zone.)

Posted by: adminEcon
Tags: , , , , , ,
Comments (0) Add a Comment