Opportunity cost of less meat: Cows grazing in a mountain pasture

Opportunity Cost & The Meat Eater’s Dilemma

Jun 4, 2014 • 383 Views

Our Wednesday environment focus: Are you a meat avoider, eater or reducer?

On a scale of meat consumption, we can place the avoiders at one end, the eaters at the other, and the reducers in the middle because they are meatless for at least one day each week.

Where are we going with this? To some meat eating tradeoffs and the opportunity cost of eating less meat.

In a 2013 paper, researchers grouped the different kinds of meat eaters to illustrate how their meat consumption could be diminished. Their concern was the massive impact of human-related livestock activity on the environment. One estimate indicates we are looking at 9% of our CO2 generation, 65% of the nitrous oxide we produce (mostly from manure) and 37% of the methane (from a lot of cow burps).

 I thought the paper’s list of our food priorities was interesting:

Meat consumption, negative externalities and climate change

From: “Sustainability and Meat Consumption: Is Reduction Realistic?”

According to one estimate, if we were to diminish the above “foodprint” by eliminating meat consumption, we could lower CO2, nitrous oxide and methane emissions by close to 20% by 2050.

Our bottom line? We need to ask the cost. How are we affecting the livelihood of the 1.3 billion people whose incomes relate to livestock? What would it mean to eradicate the need for the livestock that occupy 30% of the earth’s land surface and represent 20% of our land-based animal biomass. And, how will the people in emerging market economies respond? Looking at a ladder of development, meat eating accompanies the ascent to wealth and better nutrition.

You see where this is going. I know we are not going to eliminate meat consumption but how much should we try? Completing this opportunity cost chart could help us with an answer:

Climate change meat eating opportunity cost chart

It would be a pleasure to hear your opinion in a comment.

Sources and more...Asking what would happen if we ate no meat, this Slate article touched all of the issues and led me to this 2013 report from the LEI Wageningen University and Research Centre in the Netherlands and the 2006 FAO report.

« »